Kiddometer
HomeResortsHotel ReviewsFamily ActivitiesYour Itinerary
Back to Kiddometer
RESORT COMPARISON · ANTIGUA

Carlisle Bay vs Jumby Bay Island

Side-by-side family travel comparison
Jump to:
OverviewQuick FactsNearbyLovesWatch-outsBook
What the badges mean:FPFamily Preferred — solid family choiceFFFamily First — built around kids & teens
KIDDOMETER RECOMMENDATION

Best for most families: Carlisle Bay

FFFamily First

Carlisle Bay is truly family-first with extensive supervised kids' programming for all ages, family suites, and an all-inclusive option.

WHY CARLISLE BAY STANDS OUT
✓ All Inclusive✓ Kids Club✓ Babysitting
✓ OUR PICK
Carlisle Bay
FFFamily First

Carlisle Bay

$$$$ Per night, avg.

Carlisle Bay presents an upscale, all-suite beachfront experience set on a quiet Caribbean bay. Designed with families in mind, the resort provides spacious accommodations and a range of activities catering to various age groups.

Jumby Bay Island
FFFamily First

Jumby Bay Island

$$$$ Per night, avg.

Jumby Bay Island provides families with a secluded, high-end retreat on a private Caribbean island, offering spacious villas and direct beach access. Its kid-friendly approach ensures a comfortable and activity-rich environment for guests of all ages.

AT A GLANCE

Quick Facts

FEATURE
Carlisle Bay
Jumby Bay Island
All Inclusive
✓ Yes
Not included
Kids Club
✓ Yes
Not included
Babysitting
✓ Yes
Not included
Price
$$$$
$$$$
Best For
Families with young children, elementary-age kids, and teens seeking a comfortable all-suite resort with diverse activities and a kids' club.
Families with elementary-age children, teenagers, and multi-generational groups seeking a private, high-end Caribbean island resort with spacious accommodations.
WHAT THEY BOTH SHARE
✓ Spa✓ Beachfront✓ Family Rooms
AROUND THE RESORT

Nearby Highlights

CARLISLE BAY
→Carlisle Bay Beach — Directly on
→Carlisle Bay Marine Park (snorkeling) — Directly off the beach
→Rainforest ridge walk to Signal Hill — 30 min walk
→Nelson's Dockyard (English Harbour) — 20-25 min drive
→Shirley Heights Lookout — 20-25 min drive
JUMBY BAY ISLAND
→Dutchman's Bay / Jabberwock Beach — 7 min boat + 5-10 min drive
→Stingray City Antigua — 7 min boat + 15-20 min drive
→D-Boat Antigua — 7 min boat + 15-20 min drive
→Antigua's Donkey Sanctuary — 7 min boat + 15-20 min drive
→Nelson's Dockyard (UNESCO World Heritage Site) — 7 min boat + 40-50 min drive
THE UPSIDE

Things Families Love

CARISLE BAY ANTIGUA
✓Cool Kids Club for ages 2-7 with dedicated wading pool and playground
✓Crew Blue and Crush Programmes for older children and teens
✓Spacious two-bedroom Beach Suites and three-bedroom Carlisle Suites for larger families
✓Three family-friendly restaurants with kid-friendly menus and afternoon tea
✓Complimentary non-motorized water sports like kayaking, paddleboarding, and sailing
✓Cinema screening room with movie nights for family entertainment
JUMBY BAY ISLAND RESORT
✓Jumby Explorers kids club for ages 3-12 offers wildlife tours, water sports, and science programs
✓Dedicated teen activities including mocktail classes and conservation programs
✓All-inclusive rates cover meals, drinks, and many watersports
✓Spacious multi-bedroom villas and private residences, many with private pools
✓Hawksbill Turtle Program allows kids to participate in conservation efforts
✓Complimentary bicycles for island exploration, a car-free environment for safety
BEFORE YOU BOOK

Things to Know

CARISLE BAY ANTIGUA
!The resort is secluded, about a 40-minute drive from the airport
!One of the four restaurants is adults-only
!Babysitting services are available but cost extra
!While family-friendly, some guests have noted occasional unmanaged "free-range children" in restaurants
!The main pool is nice but not spectacular compared to some other resorts
JUMBY BAY ISLAND RESORT
!Located on a private island, accessible only by a short boat ride from Antigua
!Villas and Estates may require a three-night minimum stay
!Some private residence guests incur extra charges for dining at resort restaurants
!Babysitting and nanny services are available but cost extra
!Resort caters to both families and couples, maintaining a luxurious, relaxed atmosphere
RATES & PHOTOS

Full Profiles & Booking

Carlisle Bay
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
Jumby Bay Island
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
Browse All Resorts →