Kiddometer
HomeResortsHotel ReviewsFamily ActivitiesYour Itinerary
Back to Kiddometer
RESORT COMPARISON · ST CROIX

Cottages by the Sea vs Sugar Beach

Side-by-side family travel comparison
Jump to:
OverviewQuick FactsNearbyLovesWatch-outsBook
What the badges mean:FPFamily Preferred — solid family choiceFFFamily First — built around kids & teens
KIDDOMETER RECOMMENDATION

Best for most families: Cottages by the Sea

FBFamily Balanced

Cottages by the Sea is Family Balanced as a self-catering cottage property with no dedicated kids' programming, despite offering beach access and complimentary equipment.

✓ OUR PICK
Cottages by the Sea
FBFamily Balanced

Cottages by the Sea

$$$ Per night, avg.

Cottages by the Sea offers a laid-back, family-run beachfront experience on St. Croix, where individually decorated cottages provide full kitchens for self-catering ease. Families benefit from complimentary loaner bikes, kayaks, and beach chairs for active days exploring the Caribbean shore.

Sugar Beach
FBFamily Balanced

Sugar Beach

$$$$ Per night, avg.

Sugar Beach offers a cozy oceanfront stay directly on Sugar Beach, providing families with spacious studios and multi-bedroom suites equipped with kitchens. Its convenient location near Christiansted and essential amenities like an outdoor pool and beach access make it suitable for a relaxed family vacation.

AT A GLANCE

Quick Facts

FEATURE
Cottages by the Sea
Sugar Beach
Price
$$$
$$$$
Best For
Best for families with elementary-age children and teenagers, as well as multi-generational groups seeking a self-catering and active beachfront experience.
Best for families with young children and teenagers seeking self-catering accommodations and direct beach access.
WHAT THEY BOTH SHARE
✓ Beachfront✓ Family Rooms✓ Grocery Nearby
AROUND THE RESORT

Nearby Highlights

COTTAGES BY THE SEA
→Dorsch Beach — Directly on
→Frederiksted Pier — 0.5 mile / 10-15 min walk
→Fort Frederik — 0.7-1 mile / 15-20 min walk
→Sandy Point National Wildlife Refuge — 3-4 miles / 5-10 min drive (seasonal access)
→St. George Village Botanical Garden — 6-7 miles / 15-20 min drive
SUGAR BEACH
→Sugar Beach — Directly on
→Christiansted National Historic Site (Fort Christiansvaern) — 5 min drive
→Christiansted Boardwalk — 5 min drive
→Buck Island Reef National Monument — 5 min drive to Christiansted / then 40-90 min boat trip
→Salt River Bay National Historical Park and Ecological Preserve — 3 miles / ~10 min drive
→St. George Village Botanical Garden — ~40-45 min drive
THE UPSIDE

Things Families Love

COTTAGES BY THE SEA
✓Full kitchens in most cottages for easy self-catering and family meals
✓Direct access to a calm, clear beach perfect for swimming and snorkeling
✓Complimentary use of snorkel gear, kayaks, bikes, and beach toys
✓Coin-operated guest laundry facilities available for family convenience
✓Community patios with BBQ grills and board games for shared family fun
SUGAR BEACH CONDO RESORT
✓Spacious condominium units with full kitchens — perfect for self-catering family meals
✓Direct access to a 500-foot white sand Caribbean beachfront for easy play
✓Freshwater pool built around a historic 1700s Danish sugar mill
✓Variety of unit sizes, from studios to four-bedrooms, accommodating extended families
✓Gated property with free parking provides added security
✓Close proximity to Christiansted for exploring, dining, and grocery shopping
BEFORE YOU BOOK

Things to Know

COTTAGES BY THE SEA
!No on-site restaurant or pool, though dining is available next door
!No dedicated kids' club or supervised programming offered
!Car rental is highly recommended for exploring St. Croix from this location
!Property provides a quiet, relaxed atmosphere, not a bustling resort
SUGAR BEACH CONDO RESORT
!This is a condo resort, not a full-service hotel with a kids club or extensive on-site programming
!Beach has some sea grass, both on the sand and in the water
!No on-site restaurants, though two are within walking distance
!Facilities are limited to the pool, tennis courts, and clubhouse with BBQ grills
!Beach facilities are maintained by the condo complex, respect resident privacy
RATES & PHOTOS

Full Profiles & Booking

Cottages by the Sea
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
Sugar Beach
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
Browse All Resorts →