Kiddometer
HomeResortsHotel ReviewsFamily ActivitiesYour Itinerary
Back to Kiddometer
RESORT COMPARISON · CAYE CAULKER

Island Magic Beach Resort vs Seaside Cabanas

Side-by-side family travel comparison
Jump to:
OverviewQuick FactsNearbyLovesWatch-outsBook
What the badges mean:FPFamily Preferred — solid family choiceFFFamily First — built around kids & teens
KIDDOMETER RECOMMENDATION

Best for most families: Island Magic Beach Resort

FPFamily Preferred

Island Magic Beach Resort offers strong family amenities like a children's pool, playground, and kitchenettes, making it a preferred choice for families.

WHY ISLAND MAGIC BEACH RESORT STANDS OUT
✓ Family Rooms
✓ OUR PICK
Island Magic Beach Resort
FPFamily Preferred

Island Magic Beach Resort

$$$ Per night, avg.

This laid-back waterfront hotel on Caye Caulker offers families a relaxed Caribbean experience with comfortable suites featuring kitchens. Its private beach area and arrangements for snorkeling and diving tours cater to those seeking island adventures together.

Seaside Cabanas
FPFamily Preferred

Seaside Cabanas

$$ Per night, avg.

Seaside Cabanas offers families a laid-back island experience with its vibrant rooms and direct beach access on Caye Caulker. The hotel's outdoor pool and kid-friendly atmosphere provide a comfortable base for exploring the island's charm and the Caribbean sea.

AT A GLANCE

Quick Facts

FEATURE
Island Magic Beach Resort
Seaside Cabanas
Family Rooms
✓ Yes
Not included
Grocery Nearby
Not included
✓ Yes
Price
$$$
$$
Best For
Best for families with elementary-age children, older children, and teenagers who enjoy water activities and prefer self-catering amenities.
Best for families with elementary-age children and pre-teens seeking a relaxed, authentic island experience with direct beach and pool access.
WHAT THEY BOTH SHARE
✓ Beachfront
AROUND THE RESORT

Nearby Highlights

ISLAND MAGIC BEACH RESORT
→Playa Asuncion — Directly on
→The Split — 15 min walk
→Caye Caulker Marine Reserve (snorkeling/diving tours) — boat trip from various docks
→Tarpon Feeding Dock — 20-25 min walk
→Koko King (Northside Beach Club) — 2 min boat ride from The Split
SEASIDE CABANAS
→Front Street Beach — Directly on
→The Split — 10 min walk
→Iguana Reef Inn (Stingray feeding) — 5 min walk
→Caye Caulker Marine Reserve (snorkeling tours) — Short boat trip
→Hol Chan Marine Reserve (snorkeling tours) — Boat trip
THE UPSIDE

Things Families Love

ISLAND MAGIC BEACH RESORT
✓Beachfront location with easy access to the Caribbean Sea
✓Dedicated children's pool for younger guests
✓Rooms and suites include kitchenettes, microwaves, and refrigerators for easy meals
✓On-site playground and library offer kid-friendly entertainment
✓Bike and golf cart rentals available for island exploration
✓Close proximity to snorkeling, sailing, and marine reserves for family adventures
SEASIDE CABANAS HOTEL
✓Family-sized rooms with two double beds available
✓On-site freshwater swimming pool for relaxation
✓Direct beach access for easy water activities
✓On-site tour assistance for snorkeling and manatee excursions
✓Central location on Front Street, walking distance to island attractions
BEFORE YOU BOOK

Things to Know

ISLAND MAGIC BEACH RESORT
!The resort's main pool has a poolside bar, which can be adult-focused
!While near the action, it's south enough for a generally peaceful stay
!Caye Caulker requires a water taxi or local flight to access
!No mention of a dedicated kids' club or supervised children's programming
!The on-site restaurant, Magic Grill, serves comfort food but specific kids' menus aren't highlighted
SEASIDE CABANAS HOTEL
!Caye Caulker's beaches are more about docks than sandy lounging areas
!Golf carts and bicycles are the main transport, car rentals are not available
!Sargassum seaweed can be present seasonally, impacting beach experience
!Noise levels can sometimes be a concern, especially in central areas
!Island has a "Go Slow" vibe, less structured activities than larger resorts
RATES & PHOTOS

Full Profiles & Booking

Island Magic Beach Resort
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
Seaside Cabanas
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
Browse All Resorts →