Kiddometer
HomeResortsHotel ReviewsFamily ActivitiesYour Itinerary
Back to Kiddometer
RESORT COMPARISON · ST JOHN

Sea Shore Allure vs St. John Inn

Side-by-side family travel comparison
Jump to:
OverviewQuick FactsNearbyLovesWatch-outsBook
What the badges mean:FPFamily Preferred — solid family choiceFFFamily First — built around kids & teens
KIDDOMETER RECOMMENDATION

Best for most families: Sea Shore Allure

FPFamily Preferred

Sea Shore Allure offers strong family amenities like spacious suites with full kitchens and babysitting, but lacks dedicated kids' programming.

WHY SEA SHORE ALLURE STANDS OUT
✓ Beachfront✓ Grocery Nearby
✓ OUR PICK
Sea Shore Allure
FPFamily Preferred

Sea Shore Allure

$$$$ Per night, avg.

Sea Shore Allure offers bayfront condos with kitchens and private balconies, providing families flexible living spaces up to three bedrooms. Guests have direct access to the Caribbean bay and an outdoor pool, catering to a relaxed St. John vacation.

St. John Inn
FBFamily Balanced

St. John Inn

$$$ Per night, avg.

The St. John Inn offers families a relaxed hillside stay with rooms equipped with kitchenettes and pull-out sofas. Complimentary continental breakfast, beach equipment, and an outdoor pool enhance a comfortable family vacation.

AT A GLANCE

Quick Facts

FEATURE
Sea Shore Allure
St. John Inn
Beachfront
✓ Yes
Not included
Grocery Nearby
✓ Yes
Not included
Price
$$$$
$$$
Best For
Best for families with school-age kids and teenagers, or multi-generational groups, who appreciate self-catering accommodations and a relaxed pace.
Families with elementary-age and pre-teen children who appreciate self-catering options and access to island activities.
WHAT THEY BOTH SHARE
✓ Family Rooms
AROUND THE RESORT

Nearby Highlights

SEA SHORE ALLURE
→Frank Bay Beach — Directly on
→Virgin Islands National Park Visitor Center — 2-3 min drive
→Trunk Bay Beach — 10-12 min drive
→Maho Bay Beach — 15-20 min drive
→Annaberg Sugar Plantation — 20-25 min drive
ST. JOHN INN
→Cruz Bay Beach — 6-7 min walk
→Virgin Islands National Park Visitor Center — 8 min walk
→Mongoose Junction — 4-5 min walk
→Trunk Bay Beach — 10-15 min drive
→Annaberg Sugar Plantation Ruins — 20-25 min drive
THE UPSIDE

Things Families Love

SEA SHORE ALLURE
✓Spacious one, two, and three-bedroom suites with fully equipped kitchens for easy family meals
✓In-unit washers and dryers, perfect for keeping vacation clothes fresh
✓Private pebble beach with chairs and towels for convenient ocean access
✓Complimentary pool toys, floats, and balls for fun at the Blue Havana pool
✓Nanny and babysitting services available upon request, offering parents flexibility
✓Short walk to Cruz Bay for dining, shopping, and nearby Virgin Islands National Park access
ST. JOHN INN
✓Free rollaway beds and cribs available for little ones
✓Suites with kitchenettes, microwaves, and full-size fridges
✓Complimentary continental breakfast included daily
✓Free beach chairs, coolers, towels, and snorkel gear provided
✓Outdoor pool for refreshing dips and relaxation
✓Short walk to Cruz Bay restaurants, shops, and ferry docks
BEFORE YOU BOOK

Things to Know

SEA SHORE ALLURE
!A boutique property with only eight units, so book well in advance for family trips
!While offering babysitting, there is no dedicated kids' club or organized children's programming
!The rooftop terrace has a hot tub, which might have age restrictions or be less appealing to younger children
!Dining options are primarily self-catering in units or nearby Cruz Bay restaurants
ST. JOHN INN
!The hotel has a charming, older, and quirky vibe, not a luxury resort
!No full-service restaurant on-site for lunch or dinner
!Hillside location means a steep walk to and from Cruz Bay
!Front desk has limited hours, plan accordingly for check-in/out
RATES & PHOTOS

Full Profiles & Booking

Sea Shore Allure
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
St. John Inn
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
Browse All Resorts →