Kiddometer
HomeResortsHotel ReviewsFamily ActivitiesYour Itinerary
Back to Kiddometer
RESORT COMPARISON · ST CROIX

Tamarind Reef Resort Spa and Marina vs The Buccaneer Resort St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands

Side-by-side family travel comparison
Jump to:
OverviewQuick FactsNearbyLovesWatch-outsBook
What the badges mean:FPFamily Preferred — solid family choiceFFFamily First — built around kids & teens
KIDDOMETER RECOMMENDATION

Best for most families: The Buccaneer Resort St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands

FPFamily Preferred

The Buccaneer Resort offers a complimentary kids club, diverse family accommodations, and numerous activities, making it a strong choice for families while also welcoming adults.

WHY THE BUCCANEER RESORT ST. CROIX, U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS STANDS OUT
✓ Babysitting✓ Family Rooms
Tamarind Reef Resort Spa and Marina
FBFamily Balanced

Tamarind Reef Resort Spa and Marina

$$$$ Per night, avg.

Tamarind Reef Resort provides a quiet family retreat on a secluded Caribbean beach, where guests can enjoy complimentary water sports like snorkeling and kayaking directly from the shore. Families benefit from spacious island-style rooms, some offering kitchenettes, making extended stays comfortable and convenient.

✓ OUR PICK
The Buccaneer Resort St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands
FPFamily Preferred

The Buccaneer Resort St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands

$$$$ Per night, avg.

The Buccaneer Resort provides a range of activities and amenities designed for families, including dedicated kid-friendly programs and diverse recreational options. Its beachfront location and multi-bedroom suites create a comfortable and engaging environment for guests of all ages.

AT A GLANCE

Quick Facts

FEATURE
Tamarind Reef Resort Spa and Marina
The Buccaneer Resort St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands
Babysitting
Not included
✓ Yes
Family Rooms
Not included
✓ Yes
Price
$$$$
$$$$
Best For
Families with elementary-age children, tweens, and teens who enjoy active beach and water sports, and families seeking a quieter, secluded resort experience.
Best for families with elementary to teenage children, and multi-generational groups seeking diverse activities and a refined setting.
WHAT THEY BOTH SHARE
✓ Spa✓ Beachfront
AROUND THE RESORT

Nearby Highlights

TAMARIND REEF RESORT SPA AND MARINA
→Tamarind Reef Beach — Directly on
→Buck Island Reef National Monument — Accessible by boat tours from adjacent Green Cay Marina
→Christiansted National Historic Site/Fort Christiansvaern — 10 min drive (approx. 3.3 miles / 5.4 km)
→Point Udall — 20 min drive (approx. 9 miles / 14.6 km)
→Salt River Bay National Historical Park and Ecological Preserve (Bio Bay) — 20-25 min drive (approx. 8.7 miles / 14 km)
THE BUCCANEER RESORT ST. CROIX, U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS
→Mermaid Beach — Directly on
→Christiansted National Historic Site — 5-10 min drive
→Buck Island Reef National Monument (via boat tour from Christiansted) — 7 min drive to tour departure + boat trip
→Salt River Bay National Historical Park and Ecological Preserve — 15-20 min drive
→Sandy Point National Wildlife Refuge — 25-30 min drive
THE UPSIDE

Things Families Love

TAMARIND REEF RESORT
✓Child-friendly wading area at the resort's beach
✓Complimentary kayaks, stand-up paddleboards, and snorkel gear available
✓Rooms with kitchenettes offer convenient self-catering options
✓Outdoor swimming pool with ocean views for family fun
✓Two on-site restaurants provide diverse dining choices
✓Easy access to boat tours from the marina, including Buck Island
THE BUCCANEER
✓Complimentary Kids Camp daily for ages 4-12 with varied activities and snacks
✓Three beautiful beaches with calm waters perfect for younger swimmers
✓Free use of snorkel gear, kayaks, and paddleboards directly from the beach
✓Diverse family accommodations including suites with multiple rooms and connecting options
✓Multiple dining venues offering children's menus and a complimentary daily breakfast buffet
BEFORE YOU BOOK

Things to Know

TAMARIND REEF RESORT
!Beach can be rocky in some areas, limiting swimming in certain spots
!No dedicated kids' club or supervised children's programming
!Rooms, while clean and spacious, may feel a bit dated
!Resort is not all-inclusive, plan for additional meal costs
!Christiansted is a short drive away, so a car rental is recommended
THE BUCCANEER
!Car rental is highly recommended for exploring St. Croix beyond the resort
!Getting to the resort from the airport is about a 25-minute taxi ride
!While family-friendly, some dining options are more adult-oriented in atmosphere
!The resort is extensive and includes some hills, but courtesy transportation is available
!Babysitting services are available but incur an additional cost
RATES & PHOTOS

Full Profiles & Booking

Tamarind Reef Resort Spa and Marina
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
The Buccaneer Resort St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands
Full Profile →
Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
Browse All Resorts →