Kiddometer
HomeResortsHotel ReviewsFamily ActivitiesYour Itinerary
Back to Kiddometer

Family Resort · St Croix

The Hotel on the Cay

Best for families with elementary and pre-teen children who appreciate a private island setting with self-catering options and on-site activities.

FB
Kiddometer Family Fit
Family Balanced
The Hotel on the Cay provides a beachfront location, family-friendly accommodations, and babysitting, but lacks dedicated kids programming or a water park.
Set on a private island with sandy Caribbean beaches, The Hotel on the Cay offers a relaxed atmosphere with family-friendly accommodations including kitchenettes and a private house. Families can enjoy water sports, an activity program, and complimentary boat transfers to Christiansted.
The Hotel on the Cay
From Our Editors
Full Review
Read Our Full Review of The Hotel on the Cay →

This relaxed hotel provides a unique island experience, situated on its own private cay with sandy Caribbean beaches and views overlooking Christiansted Harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back, with retro-style rooms designed for comfort. Families will appreciate the various accommodation options, from rooms with kitchenettes and balconies to suites featuring pull-out sofas and a private one-bedroom house with a full kitchen, providing flexibility for self-catering. The resort includes an outdoor pool, water sports, and an activity program to keep all ages engaged. While on a private island, guests benefit from complimentary boat transfers to Christiansted, placing them just 7 km from the Christiansted National Historic Site for easy exploration. This hotel suits families looking for a tranquil island stay with the convenience of self-catering options and accessible activities.

At a Glance

Family Snapshot

✓ Beachfront✓ Family Rooms
✦

Things Families Love

  • ✓Location on a private cay with a short, frequent ferry to Christiansted
  • ✓On-site beach with clear, shallow waters perfect for swimming and snorkeling
  • ✓St. Croix Water Sports Center offers gear rentals and free mini-lessons
  • ✓Suites and two-bedroom apartments with kitchenettes are ideal for families
  • ✓Babysitting/child care services are available for parents seeking adult time

Things to Know

  • !The hotel has a simple, somewhat dated aesthetic
  • !The on-site pool is temporarily closed
  • !The main restaurant offers average food, but many dining options are a short ferry ride away
  • !You'll need to use the ferry or taxi for groceries and most island excursions
  • !No dedicated kids club or extensive supervised children's programming
✦
Logistics

Quick Facts

Price$$$$ · Luxury
Price NoteFrom $400-$600+/night in peak season for a family of 4, depending on room type and exact dates.
Star Rating3 stars
Best ForBest for families with elementary and pre-teen children who appreciate a private island setting with self-catering options and on-site activities.
AddressProtestant Cay, Christiansted, 00822, U.S. Virgin Islands
✦
Around the Resort

Nearby Highlights

→ Protestant Cay BeachDirectly on (hotel's private beach)
→ Christiansted National Historic Site / Fort Christiansvaern2 min ferry + short walk
→ Buck Island Reef National Monument30 min boat trip from Christiansted
→ Salt River Bay National Historical Park and Ecological Preserve (Bioluminescent Bay)15-20 min drive
→ Rainbow Beach30-35 min drive
✦
Rates & Photos

View More

Prices change frequently — check current rates across multiple booking sites to find the best deal.

Booking.com →Expedia →Hotels.com →
✦
Side by Side

Compare Resorts

the buccaneer vs tamarind reef resort →sugar beach condo resort vs cottages by the sea →
← Compare St Croix ResortsBrowse All Resorts →