FB
Kiddometer Family Fit
Family Balanced
The Hotel on the Cay provides a beachfront location, family-friendly accommodations, and babysitting, but lacks dedicated kids programming or a water park.
Set on a private island with sandy Caribbean beaches, The Hotel on the Cay offers a relaxed atmosphere with family-friendly accommodations including kitchenettes and a private house. Families can enjoy water sports, an activity program, and complimentary boat transfers to Christiansted.

This relaxed hotel provides a unique island experience, situated on its own private cay with sandy Caribbean beaches and views overlooking Christiansted Harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back, with retro-style rooms designed for comfort. Families will appreciate the various accommodation options, from rooms with kitchenettes and balconies to suites featuring pull-out sofas and a private one-bedroom house with a full kitchen, providing flexibility for self-catering. The resort includes an outdoor pool, water sports, and an activity program to keep all ages engaged. While on a private island, guests benefit from complimentary boat transfers to Christiansted, placing them just 7 km from the Christiansted National Historic Site for easy exploration. This hotel suits families looking for a tranquil island stay with the convenience of self-catering options and accessible activities.
At a GlanceFamily Snapshot
✓ Beachfront✓ Family Rooms
✦
The UpsideThings Families Love
- ✓Location on a private cay with a short, frequent ferry to Christiansted
- ✓On-site beach with clear, shallow waters perfect for swimming and snorkeling
- ✓St. Croix Water Sports Center offers gear rentals and free mini-lessons
- ✓Suites and two-bedroom apartments with kitchenettes are ideal for families
- ✓Babysitting/child care services are available for parents seeking adult time
Before You BookThings to Know
- !The hotel has a simple, somewhat dated aesthetic
- !The on-site pool is temporarily closed
- !The main restaurant offers average food, but many dining options are a short ferry ride away
- !You'll need to use the ferry or taxi for groceries and most island excursions
- !No dedicated kids club or extensive supervised children's programming
✦
LogisticsQuick Facts
| Price | $$$$ · Luxury |
| Price Note | From $400-$600+/night in peak season for a family of 4, depending on room type and exact dates. |
| Star Rating | 3 stars |
| Best For | Best for families with elementary and pre-teen children who appreciate a private island setting with self-catering options and on-site activities. |
| Address | Protestant Cay, Christiansted, 00822, U.S. Virgin Islands |
✦
Around the ResortNearby Highlights
→ Protestant Cay BeachDirectly on (hotel's private beach)
→ Christiansted National Historic Site / Fort Christiansvaern2 min ferry + short walk
→ Buck Island Reef National Monument30 min boat trip from Christiansted
→ Salt River Bay National Historical Park and Ecological Preserve (Bioluminescent Bay)15-20 min drive
→ Rainbow Beach30-35 min drive
✦
Rates & PhotosView More
Prices change frequently — check current rates across multiple booking sites to find the best deal.
✦
Side by SideCompare Resorts