St Martin content covers its top regions well enough, but it rarely addresses the decision that actually shapes a family’s trip from the start: which half of this two-nation island to base yourself on. The French and Dutch sides aren’t just different neighborhoods — different currency, different pace, and a genuinely different kind of vacation depending on which one you pick.
Filter out the noise and find what works for your family.
Every resort we review gets one of four Family Fit ratings. The rating is based on kids programming, amenities, vibe, and who the resort actually markets to - not just whether they allow children.
Discover My Ideal Resort →The Short Version
- The French side (Saint-Martin) uses euros, has a quieter, more European pace, and offers calmer, more varied beaches — Orient Bay, Baie Rouge, and Friar’s Bay are all here
- The Dutch side (Sint Maarten) uses US dollars, tends to stretch further for American visitors, and has a busier, more activity-driven atmosphere with casinos around Maho and Simpson Bay
- For kid-friendly infrastructure, the Dutch side has more resort amenities and organized activities, while the French side has calmer beaches, easier driving, and less crowding but fewer built-in resort extras
- Maho Beach on the Dutch side is famous for plane-spotting but isn’t recommended for actual swimming due to jet blast from the adjacent airport runway
- Traffic congestion is noticeably worse on the Dutch side given its greater concentration of people and activity
- Dining runs premium on the French side, especially in Grand Case, while the Dutch side offers a broader price range from casual to fine dining
Currency and Cost: A Real, Practical Difference
This is the detail that catches first-time visitors off guard: Saint-Martin runs on euros, while Sint Maarten uses the US dollar. For American families, that exchange rate generally means your money stretches a bit further on the Dutch side. It’s a small thing on paper, but it adds up across a week of meals, activities, and incidentals, and it’s worth factoring into which side you base yourself on if budget is a real consideration for your trip.
Pace and Atmosphere: Quiet vs. Busy
The French side has a distinctly quieter, more European character — think pastry shops with fresh baguettes, French spoken widely, and low-key bars rather than a nightlife scene. The Dutch side is the busier, more animated half of the island, with a more tourist-heavy energy and Maho and Simpson Bay’s glittering casinos as the standard evening options. For families with young kids who are in bed by 8, this distinction matters less for nightlife itself and more for daytime pace — the French side simply feels calmer to move around in, with less traffic and fewer crowds, while the Dutch side’s greater concentration of people and activity also means more congestion on the roads.
Beaches: Variety vs. Convenience
The French side has the edge on beach variety and calm water — Orient Bay, Baie Rouge, and Friar’s Bay all sit here, offering quieter, more varied options with less crowding. The Dutch side’s beaches tend to be busier, and its most famous one, Maho Beach, is a novelty rather than a real swimming destination for families — the jet blast from planes landing at the adjacent airport is a genuine hazard, not just a photo-op curiosity, and it’s not a spot to plan actual beach time around with kids.
Which Side Actually Suits Your Family
If your family wants a relaxed, independent trip built around calm beaches and easy driving, with less reliance on organized resort activities, the French side is the better fit — the tradeoff is less built-in resort infrastructure, so you’re doing more of the planning yourself. If your family would rather have a resort handle logistics, with more kid-oriented amenities and pre-arranged activities on site, the Dutch side’s stronger resort infrastructure makes that easier, at the cost of more crowds and traffic. Neither choice locks you out of the other side entirely — the island is small enough that a day trip across the border is simple — but picking a “home base” side based on which of these tradeoffs matters more to your family is worth doing before you book.
Getting More Specific: Towns and Beaches Worth Knowing by Side
Beyond the broad French-vs-Dutch framing, it helps to know a few specific spots on each side. On the French side, Grand Case is the destination’s food-focused village — a boulevard of restaurants and lolo grill stands right on a calm beach, while Marigot serves as the capital with its harbor market and Fort Louis overlook. On the Dutch side, Simpson Bay centers on the lagoon and its marina-adjacent restaurants and nightlife, while Philipsburg’s Front Street and boardwalk offer the most concentrated shopping and cruise-ship-driven energy on the island. Orient Bay, Baie Rouge, and Friar’s Bay — all French side — tend to be quieter and more varied for a beach day, while Maho and Simpson Bay’s Kim Sha Beach lean busier and more resort-adjacent on the Dutch side.
Quick Answers
- Which side is cheaper for an American family? The Dutch side, generally — it uses US dollars, and the exchange rate on the French side’s euros works against American visitors.
- Which side has calmer beaches for kids? The French side — Orient Bay, Baie Rouge, and Friar’s Bay all offer calmer, more varied options than the Dutch side’s busier beaches.
- Is Maho Beach good for swimming with kids? No — it’s a plane-spotting novelty, but the jet blast from the adjacent runway makes it unsuitable for actual swimming.
Things to Do in St Martin
Browse family-friendly tours and activities in St Martin, ranked from real traveler reviews.
Where to Stay in St Martin
A few family-friendly places to base your trip:
La Samanna, A Belmond Hotel
Grand Case Beach Club
Sonesta Maho Beach Resort & Casino
Divi Little Bay Beach Resort
Sapphire Beach Club ResortReady to Plan Your St Martin Trip?
Get a personalized family itinerary built around your kids ages, interests, and travel style — free.
